Monday, February 7, 2011

Universal Bosch Mixer Vs. KitchenAid Mixer

Ok...so here goes...

I have owned a Universal Bosch since I was married over 6 years ago, and I love it, but I have always wondered what it would be like to use a KitchenAid mixer.  I talked to my mom about it last year and she said that she once bought a Kitchen Aid because it just looked so nice, and everyone (meaning, Martha Stewart and Rachel Ray) were using one.  After using it for a little while and especially for making bread, she returned it because it just didn't measure up to her Bosch.

Yesterday, I had the opportunity to use a KitchenAid Mixer for making bread.  There are several things I didn't like about it.  1. I don't like how the mixer arm is right in the middle of the bowl, therefore getting in the way of whatever you want to do. ie, adding ingredients or feeling for the consistency of the dough.  2. I was using the flat beater attachment (which I think was the wrong attachment for mixing dough) and as the ingredients were being worked into a dough, it all stuck to the attachment and just rolled around the bowl instead of actually kneading it.  I must admit that I was making a 100% whole wheat bread and so the dough was heaver than with other kinds of bread, but my Bosch doesn't have a problem with kneading at all!!!  I can knead 7 lbs of Whole Wheat dough in my Bosch and it doesn't blink an eye.  I know I probably am not comparing apples to apples, but below is directly from the Pleasant Hill Grain Company website.  Makers of the Universal Bosch. http://www.pleasanthillgrain.com/bosch_universal.aspx


The Bosch Mixer has More Power: For starters, the Bosch Mixer has a 700 watt motor. Our biggest competitor (the sales-volume leader) calls their strongest model the "Professional." Its motor is only 525 watts. Universal's motor is more than 1.3X stronger than their best. Power to mix better and last longer.
The Bosch Mixer has a Stronger Transmission: Even more important than the motor is the transmission, which converts motor power into work. Our mass-marketing competitors build transmissions with inexpensive spur gears. The first shortcoming of spur gears is that they break under stress. Stress is a bowl full of bread dough or a triple batch of oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. Things you need your mixer to handle. Buyers tell us frequently that they're getting a Bosch Mixer now because their other mixer, often brand new, failed.
The Bosch Mixer is More Efficient: The second major problem with spur gears is that even before they break, they transmit torque poorly. Torque is the ability to exert power at low turning speed — exactly what's required of a good mixer. The Universal's competition starts with a much smaller motor, then spends a big share of it on friction. Which is why many big mixers have surprisingly little oomph.

The Bosch Belt: Universal's transmission uses a belt drive design so strong that fewer than 1% have failed within twenty years. And that's twenty years of heavier work than most mixers ever see, because the Universal's reputation as a workhorse causes it to be purchased by a higher percentage of cooks who place high demands on their equipment. The belt drive of the Bosch Mixer also prevents motor failures from the heat that develops in the cramped gear enclosures of overhead drive machines, a major cause of "mixer meltdown" in other machines.


Universal Bosch


Kitchen Aid Mixer


If you have a Kitchen Aid, certainly continue to use it and be sure you have the right attachments for the job, but if you are looking into buying a mixer, I would have to say to go for the Bosch. 

The price of a top of the line Kitchen Aid is $499.99  (575 Watts) http://www.kitchenaid.com/flash.cmd?/#/product/KL26M8XOB/

The price of the Universal Bosch Plus (which is a step above what I have at 700 W) is $499.98 (800 Watts)http://www.pleasanthillgrain.com/Bosch_Universal_Plus_Mixer_MUM6N10UC.aspx

You decide, and happy mixing.

9 comments:

  1. My friend Jona posted the following on my Facebook Page about this entry, and I wanted to share it here too!!

    Couldn't agree more, the Bosch is wonderful. I spent many years of envy watching Your Mom knead out multiple loaves of whole wheat bread while I toiled kneading my two loaves. My old mixer died and it was time for a new one, I checked prices and features and even took a KitchenAid home, made a batch and wasn't happy. Returned it and ordered the Bosch from Pleasant Hill Grain Company. Happy baking ever since

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you about the KitchenAid. I do have one, it is the pro series 600 so the bowl lifts up and down. I also have the Osterizer one. It is extremely old and my husband wanted to show his appreciation for all my efforts and went out and bought me the KitchenAid. But I will have to tell you that it doesn't hold a candle to the Osterizer when it comes to bread. The only reason I use it is that I don't want to offend my dear good man. Anyway I do like it for making cakes etc. Although it is not good for small batches of anything. He bought it for me because all the cooks on TV are using it. lol
    My steadfast Osterizer is standing by.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I actually enjoyed reading through this posting.Many thanks.


    Dough Mixers

    ReplyDelete
  4. They offer excellent mixing performance, precise control, and flexibility at every speed. All stand mixers are designed for tough mixing but you need to be aware that every mixer is not designed to mix the heaviest bread or pizza doughs.Pizza Conveyor Ovens

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bosch is surely one of the best brands in the market today. It is more powerful than the professional models of other brands.

    Bosch Mixer

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have a question about the Bosch. Can you use store bought flour (like Gold Medal) to make bread in the bosch? I am looking at replacing my Kitchen Aid. I have had it close to 20 years and it still works fine, but I can only do 2 loaves of bread at a time and still have to knead it when done. It seems everything I have seen about the Bosch the people are always using freshly milled flour. I can't do that. Will the Bosch only work with freshly milled flour?
    Thank you for your help.

    Niki

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you my dear, keep an eye out for the rest of it :)
    I liked ur blogs very much and image formant is very helpful.
    Kitchen Equipment

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bosch is surely one of the best brands in the market today. It is more powerful than the professional models of other brands.
    kitchenaid artisan blender

    ReplyDelete
  9. Niki...sorry it has taken me so long to respond, but you can use your bosh with any flour. Sometimes when i am in a pinch, and don't have any wheat to grind, I use store bought, and it mixes with it just fine!!

    ReplyDelete